Technology

Google's Gemini Commercial Faces Backlash Over Gouda Cheese Claim

Published February 6, 2025

Google's Gemini Super Bowl advertisement is under fire for making an incorrect statement about Gouda cheese. The claim that Gouda cheese represents "50 to 60 percent of the world's cheese consumption" has sparked criticism online, particularly from users who pointed out the inaccuracy.

The controversy began when the commercial, which features a Wisconsin cheese business employing AI, went live. The error was initially highlighted by a user on X, Nate Hake. In a screenshot from the ad, the dubious Gouda statistic was clearly visible, but Google has since removed the claim.

In a conversation about the issue, a professor from Cornell University stated that while Gouda is indeed a popular cheese variety, it is "almost assuredly not the most widely consumed". This misleading information appears to have originated from a website, Cheese.com, which users had challenged even eleven years ago on Reddit.

Google's Gemini is its advanced AI assistant that can generate responses to queries and is accessible on both Android and iOS platforms. This recent ad mishap demonstrates a fundamental challenge with AI: the potential to provide inaccurate facts.

Google Quickly Responds to Criticism

After substantial backlash, Google acted swiftly to correct the misinformation in its Super Bowl ad. Nate Hake's original post on X caught the attention of Jerry Dischler, who oversees cloud applications at Google. Dischler responded to Hake, asserting that the claim was not a hallucination, as AI is supposed to be grounded in the information available on the web.

Dischler insisted that the statistic had been cited on multiple websites, but he acknowledged that it had been edited out of the ad shortly after Hake's comments. Hake responded to the tech giant's explanation, emphasizing the importance of accurate information.

This incident serves as a reminder of the limitations of AI technology. While AI, such as Google's Gemini, is being billed as the future of productivity, this situation has shown that it can still produce errors. Whether it's for research purposes or information gathering, users should always verify AI-generated data for accuracy.

Google, AI, cheese